Controversial provision withdrawn from ESA amendments

In a statement delivered August 19, 1996, Minister of Labour Elizabeth Witmer announced the withdrawal from Bill 49, the Employment Standards Improvement Act, of the provision allowing unions and employers to contract out of certain employment standards. (For a description of the earlier version of the Bill, see “Changes to Employment Standards Act imminent” on our Publications page. For a description of more recent developments, see ESA amendments receive royal assent” and “Red Tape Commission urges key amendments to Ontario employment statutes” on our Publications page).

The provision would have permitted parties to negotiate their own standards for hours of work, severance pay, overtime pay, public holidays and vacation pay. The negotiated standards would have prevailed over those in the ESA only if, as a package, they provided greater rights or benefits than those in the legislation. Because different types of standards were involved, there was some uncertainty as to how it would be determined whether the negotiated package, taken as a whole, exceeded the statutory minimum.

Labour Minister Witmer announced that the provision would be dropped from Bill 49 and moved into the comprehensive review of the ESA planned for this fall.

Related Articles

Comment Period Open on Proposed Regulations Regarding Incoming Paid Medical Leave Under the Canada Labour Code

On December 17, 2021, Bill C-3, An Act to amend the Criminal Code and the Canada Labour Code, received Royal Assent. …

Arbitrator Dismisses Union Grievance Regarding Decision Not to Fill Position After Employee’s Retirement

On May 17, 2022, Emond Harnden’s very own Sébastien Huard and Marianne Abou-Hamad successfully represented their client in a grievance…

Arbitrator Upholds University’s Decision to Terminate Financial Officer with Lengthy History of Performance Issues and Workplace Conflict

On May 17, 2022, Arbitrator Kathleen O’Neil released her decision in The Ontario Secondary Schools Teachers’ Federation, Local 35 and…